| Date | Day | Opponent | Site | Time | Result | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| November 20 | Saturday | Augustana | Away | 2 p.m. | W 66-65 | University of Chicago Tournament | November 21 | Sunday | University of Chicago | Away | noon | W 66-54 | Championship Game |
| November 23 | Tuesday | Baldwin-Wallace | Home | 7 p.m. | L 56-73 | N/A |
| December 1 | Wednesday | Earlham | Home | 7:30 p.m. | W 80-66 | NCAC Game |
| December 4 | Saturday | Thomas More | Home | 1 p.m. | W 86-62 | Four Players in Double Figures |
| December 8 | Wednesday | Defiance | Away | 7:30 p.m. | L 58-74 | N/A |
| December 11 | Saturday | Oberlin | Home | 2 p.m. | L 66-72 | NCAC Game |
| December 28 | Tuesday | Hanover | Home | 8 p.m. | W 80-60 | Calvin 68, Case Reserve 57 |
| December 29 | Wednesday | Calvin | Home | 3 p.m. | L 62-66 | Wittenberg-Kiwanis Championship Game |
| January 3 | Monday | Capital | Away | 7:30 p.m. | L 86-72 | N/A |
| January 7 | Friday | Hiram | Home | 6 p.m. | W 84-53 | M. JayJohn 12 points |
| January 8 | Saturday | Allegheny | Home | 2 p.m. | W 70-55 | A. Schmehl 17 points |
| January 12 | Wednesday | Ohio Wesleyan | Away | 7:30 p.m. | L 67-78 | NCAC Game |
| January 15 | Saturday | Kenyon | Away | 2 p.m. | W 69-66 | A. Johnston 17 points |
| January 18 | Tuesday | Denison | Home | 7:30 p.m. | W 71-54 | A. Schmehl 17 points |
| January 22 | Saturday | Wooster | Home | 2 p.m. | W 66-62 | A. Sherman 15 points |
| January 26 | Wednesday | Earlham | Away | 7:30 p.m. | W 76-67 | A. Sherman 17 points |
| January 29 | Saturday | Oberlin | Away | 2 p.m. | L 56-75 | NCAC Game |
| February 4 | Friday | Allegheny | Away | 5:30 p.m. | L 52-62 | NCAC Game |
| February 5 | Saturday | Hiram | Away | 5 p.m. | W 61-57 | A. Johnston 16 points |
| February 9 | Wednesday | Kenyon | Home | 7:30 p.m. | L 38-43 | NCAC Game |
| February 12 | Saturday | Ohio Wesleyan | Home | 2 p.m. | L 62-72 | NCAC Game |
| February 16 | Wednesday | Denison | Away | 7:30 p.m. | W 73-69 | T. Keller 16 points | February 19 | Saturday | Wooster | Away | 2 p.m. | W 82-80 (ot) | M. JayJohn 14 points, 9 rebounds |
| February 22 | Tuesday | Earlham | Home | 6 p.m. | L 46-59 | NCAC Quarterfinal Game |